There's no fixed number for how much TVL remains after incentives end, but on average, purely incentive-driven protocols retain only 20%–45%, while those that embed incentives into their core economic model can achieve over 90% retention. After its incentive program ended, Unichain's TVL plunged 86%, nearly wiping out its peak. In contrast, Liquity, which never relied on incentives but generates real revenue through its liquidation mechanism, saw a 1.23x retention increase.
A leading global cryptocurrency platform,suitable for both beginners and experienced traders.
New user benefit: 20% off trading fees upon registration!！
Identify Which "Retention Type" Your Project Belongs To
Protocols structured differently can see vastly different outcomes after incentives end.
Case A: "Renting liquidity" model. Incentives are the only reason to attract capital; there's no real revenue or product stickiness. These projects typically see retention below 0.45x (i.e., TVL shrinks by more than 55%). Unichain spent $21 million on incentives, yet its TVL plummeted 86% from its peak because the protocol offered no "moat" to keep LPs around once rewards stopped.
Case B: Incentives deeply tied to core business. Incentives aren't just throwing money around, but are embedded into real demand like lending or leveraged yield farming. These projects can achieve retention of 0.90x or higher. For instance, Alpaca Finance on BNB Chain saw 1.53x retention because leveraged yield farming provided functional value beyond the incentives. dYdX's market maker incentives maintained capital through gradual vesting and sustained protocol demand.
Case C: No incentives, purely protocol revenue. Liquity has never offered token incentives, but its liquidation mechanism allows stablecoin providers to earn net gains from liquidations. As a result, its TVL grew from $1.65 billion to $2.03 billion, a retention rate of 1.23x. This type of retention is the most robust because returns come from the protocol itself, not from subsidies.
Predict Retention Based on Incentive Exit Strategy
How incentives end also heavily influences where funds go.
Cliff End: Incentives drop from 100% to 0 suddenly on day 90. LPs face a "sudden power-off" moment where yields vanish instantly, causing funds to flee en masse that same day. Unichain is a textbook example.
Tapered End: Incentives step down gradually (e.g., 1000 → 750 → 500 → 250 tokens/day), giving LPs and the protocol time to adjust. Protocols with tapered exits average a 0.81x retention rate, while cliff exits average only 0.45x.
Assess Whether the Protocol Has a 'Real Demand' Moat
The only core variable that determines retention is: whether capital can still earn money or gain other value after incentives end.
What to do: Check the protocol's fee revenue over the past 30 days, and whether that revenue covers the incentive spending over the same period.
How: Look up the protocol's Revenue and Fees on DefiLlama. If revenue is far lower than the value of tokens emitted during the same period, the protocol is still "buying growth" with incentives, and retention after the incentive ends will likely collapse.
Completion standard: Calculate the ratio of "protocol's monthly real income ÷ monthly incentive spending." If it's below 1, funds will most likely move elsewhere after incentives end.
How to Verify Actions
One week before incentives end, start monitoring the protocol's daily TVL change rate. If TVL is already declining before the end, funds are exiting early—this is a preview of what will happen after. Within 7–14 days after incentives officially end, TVL will reach a new equilibrium; that number is the "real retained TVL."
A leading global cryptocurrency platform,suitable for both beginners and experienced traders.
New user benefit: 20% off trading fees upon registration!！
Next Steps
If you're providing liquidity and the protocol's incentives are about to end, start evaluating whether to exit two weeks beforehand. Check if the protocol has announced a tapered exit or a next-generation incentive plan. If there's no follow-up plan and the protocol's income cannot cover incentive spending, consider withdrawing your LP position 3–5 days before incentives end to avoid extra losses from slippage during a mass exit.
